(+92) 0317 1118263
Online Fatwa Darulifta Binoria Fatwa Binoria

Let it be known that there are two Sects among the Shias

Sacrifice and Slaughter,Rules of Slaughter,Let it be known that there are two Sects among the Shias

Fatwa No :
4176
| Date :

Fatwa No : 4176
Let it be known that there are two Sects among the Shias
عبادات / قربانی و ذبیحہ / احکام ذبح

Let it be known that there are two Sects among the Shias

Assalamu Alaikum Mufthi Sahib, Most of our respected Ulemas declare the slaughtering of Rafizi (Shi'a) as Haram whereas Hazrath Moulana Ashraf Ali Thanvi Sahib (Rah) in his Imadaadul Fataawa (4/608) has said that the correct and the upheld veiw is that it is permissible. So should we take the view of the majority of the Ulamas or of Moulana Ashraf Ali Thanvi Sahib's (Rahmathullahi alaihi)?

الجوابُ حامِدا ًو مُصلیِّا ً

Let it be known that there are two Sects among the Shias. 1. Shia Thafdheeliya and 2. Shia Isna Ashriyya. The ruling which appears in Imdadul Fatawa (Vol 3. Page 208) is in connection with those Shias who are not Kafirs or opinions differ with regard to their Kufr. Whereas those Shias of whom the Kufr is agreed upon, such as Shia Isna Ashriyya, their ruling is mentioned with complete details in Imdadul Fatawa (Vol 4. Page 856-7) that the animal slaughtered by them is Haram and it is not permissible to enter into matrimonial contracts with them. Therefore should refrain from having unnecessary worries or developing misunderstandings about pious elders.

And Allah knows best
Darulifta Jamia Binoria Aalamia

Fatwa No 4176 Verify Now
| | | | | | English
0     2920
Related Fatawa Related Fatawa

  • Ruling of the Slaughtering of a Sacrificial Animal Performed by a Woman

    Unicode   Scanned   English   0 Rules of Slaughter

  • Someone is hunting with a gun. When he fires he recites Takbeer

    Scanned   English   1 Rules of Slaughter

  • If a Kafir slaughters after reciting Bismillah is it allowed to eat?

    Scanned   English   1 Rules of Slaughter

  • Qurbani of animal who fed by hormone injections are Haram

    Scanned   English   0 Rules of Slaughter

  • Performing Aqeeqa after the Birth of Youngest Son without Having Performed it for Older Sons

    English   0 Rules of Slaughter

  • While slaughtering a goat, cutting of how many veins is praiseworthy

    English   0 Rules of Slaughter

  • If a person bought an animal before Eid with the intention of Qurbani and sold it

    English   0 Rules of Slaughter

  • Can money be given after the birth of a child instead of performing an Aqeeqa?

    English   0 Rules of Slaughter

  • Let it be known that there are two Sects among the Shias

    English   0 Rules of Slaughter

  • giving Qurbani meat to a non-Muslim?

    English   0 Rules of Slaughter

  • The Shariah ruling on sacrificing a two-year-old cow if its teeth have not yet come out.

    Unicode   English   0 Rules of Slaughter

  • Ruling on Performing ‘Aqiqah by Purchasing and Distributing Meat

    Unicode   English   0 Rules of Slaughter
...
Related Topics Relative Topics