(+92) 0317 1118263

The Ruling on Three Divorces Pronounced in Separate Sessions

Laws of Divorce,Divorce,The Ruling on Three Divorces Pronounced in Separate Sessions

Fatwa No :
99691
| Date :
2026-09-23
معاملات / احکام طلاق / طلاق

The Ruling on Three Divorces Pronounced in Separate Sessions

What do the respected Islamic scholars say regarding the following matter?
My husband gave me one divorce in 2012, after which he reconciled with me. Then, in 2018, he said to me, “If you use abusive language again, then you are divorced.” I used abusive language, but we continued living together afterward.
In 2025, he said,“If I spend the night here on the night of October 1, then you are divorced. However, he did not spend that night here; rather, he spent the night at the place where he works.
A few days ago, during an argument, he said Divorce, divorce”twice. He did not say,“I am giving you divorce”or“I will give you divorce, or anything similar.
I would now like to know whether divorce took effect through any of these statements or not. Can we continue living together as husband and wife?

الجوابُ حامِدا ًو مُصلیِّا ً

If the statement recorded above is factually correct and based on the actual circumstances, then, in the matter under consideration, after the questioner’s husband gave her the first divorce in 2012, he reconciled with her in accordance with Islamic law. Therefore, the reconciliation was valid and the marriage continued as before. After that, the husband had only two divorces remaining at his disposal.
Thereafter, when he made the second divorce conditional by saying, “If you use abusive language again, then you are divorced,” and the questioner subsequently did use abusive language, another divorce took effect. If, after that, he reconciled with her during the period of iddah (before the completion of three menstrual cycles), either verbally or through conduct, then the reconciliation was valid and the marriage continued as before. However, from that point onward, the husband had only one divorce remaining.
Accordingly, after the husband subsequently said, “If I spend the night here on the night of October 1, then you are divorced,” no further divorce took effect because the stipulated condition did not occur.
However, on the fourth occasion, during an argument, when the husband said the words “Divorce, divorce” twice to the questioner, one further divorce took effect. Thus, three divorces have now taken effect, resulting in hurmat-e-mughallazah (final and irrevocable prohibition). Reconciliation is no longer possible, nor can the two parties enter into a new marriage contract without Shar‘i halalah. The woman is free to marry another person after completing her period of iddah.
Shar‘i halalah means that, after separating from her first husband and completing her iddah, the woman genuinely marries another Muslim man without any prior condition or arrangement. If the second husband subsequently divorces her—whether immediately after one instance of marital intercourse (which is necessary for the occurrence of Shar‘i halalah) or after some period of married life—or if he does not divorce her but dies before her, then, after she completes her iddah, if she wishes to marry her first husband again and the first husband is also willing to accept her, they may enter into a new marriage contract in the presence of witnesses and with a new mahr, and thereafter live together as husband and wife.
However, entering into a marriage with the condition or prior arrangement that the second husband will divorce the woman after marital intercourse so that she can subsequently remarry her first husband is makruh tahrimi (prohibitively disliked), and a warning regarding this practice is also mentioned in the Hadith. Therefore, such an arrangement must be avoided. A subsequent marriage to another husband without such a condition or prior arrangement is, without doubt, permissible and valid.

مأخَذُ الفَتوی

کما في الدر المختار: (هي استدامة الملك القائم) بلا عوض ما دامت (في العدة) أي عدة الدخول حقيقة. اهـ (باب الرجعة، ج: 3، ص: 397-398، ط: إيج إيم سعيد)
وفي رد المحتار: نعم لو طلقها وهو مقيم معها يعاشرها معاشرة الأزواج ليس لها التزوج لعدم انقضاء عدتها منه كما سيأتي بيانه في العدة.اهـ (باب الرجعة، ج: 3، ص: 421، ط: إيج إيم سعيد)
فی الهندية : متى كرر لفظ الطلاق بحرف الواو أو بغير حرف الواو يتعدد الطلاق ( کتاب الطلاق، الباب الثانی، الفصل الاول فی الطلاق الصریح، ج :1 ، ص : 356 ، ط : مكتبة ماجدية )
وفی ردالمحتار تحت قوله: ( لتركه الإضافة ) ولا یلزم کون الإضافة صريحة في كلامه ، لما فی البحر لو قال طالق فقیل له من عنیت ؟ فقال امرأتی طُلقت امرأته. (إلى قوله) لما مر من أنه لو أخبر بالطلاق كاذبا لا يقع ديانة بخلاف الهازل، فهذا يدل على وقوعه وإن لم يضفه إلى المرأة صريحا، نعم يمكن حمله على ما إذا لم يقل إني أردت الحلف بطلاق غيرها فلا يخالف ما في البزازية ويؤيده ما في البحر لو قال: امرأة طالق أو قال طلقت امرأة ثلاثا وقال لم أعن امرأتي يصدق اهـ ويفهم منه أنه لو لم يقل ذلك تطلق امرأته، لأن العادة أن من له امرأة إنما يحلف بطلاقها لا بطلاق غيرها، فقوله إني حلفت بالطلاق ينصرف إليها ما لم يرد غيرها لأنه يحتمله كلامه. إلخ ( باب صریح الطلاق، ج : 3 ، ص : 248 ، ط : إيج إيم سعید )
وفی بدائع الصنائع : وأما الطلقات الثلاث فحكمها الأصلي هو زوال الملك، وزوال حل المحلية (إلى قوله) سواء طلقها ثلاثا متفرقا أو جملة واحدة. ( کتاب الطلاق ، فصل فی حکم الطلاق البائن ، ج: 3، ص: 187، ط: إيج إيم سعيد)
وفي الدر المختار: (لا) ينكح (مطلقة) من نكاح صحيح نافذ (إلى قوله) كما سنحققه (بها) أي بالثلاث (لو حرة وثنتين لو أمة) ولو قبل الدخول (إلى قوله) (حتى يطأها غيره إلخ (باب الرجعة، ج: 3، ص: 409-410، ط: إيج إيم سعيد)
وفيه أيضا: (وكره) التزوج للثاني (تحريما) لحديث "لعن المحلل والمحلل له" (بشرط التحليل) كتزوجتك على أن أحللك (وإن حلت للأول) (إلى قوله) (أما إذا أضمر ذلك لا) يكره (وكان) الرجل (مأجورا) لقصد الإصلاح، وتأويل اللعن إذا شرط الأجر ذكره البزازي.اهـ (باب الرجعة، ج: 3، ص: 415، ط: إيج إيم سعيد)

And Allah knows best
قاضی محمد اللہ عُفی عنه
دار الافتاء جامعه بنوریه عالمیه

Fatwa No 99691 Verify Now
0     105
Related Fatawa Related Fatawa
...
Related Topics Relative Topics